Skip to content

Should Black Americans Not Pay Taxes as a Form of Reparation?

Democrat Rep. Jasmine Crockett argued that Black Americans could be exempt from taxes as a form of reparations, but her logic is deeply flawed.

Rep. Jasmine Crockett, a Democrat hailing from Texas, recently mused about exempting Black Americans from paying taxes as a form of reparations. Yet, even in her proposal, Crockett stumbled upon a glaring inconsistency: a significant portion of the demographic she aims to assist isn’t shouldering a tax burden in the first instance. This revelation doesn’t just underscore the flawed logic at the heart of her proposal; it highlights the broader issue with the reparations debate — a lack of practical, well-thought-out solutions.

Crockett’s comments unveiled a deeper truth about the reparations conversation: it’s more about virtue signaling from the left than about crafting actionable, beneficial policies. The concept of skipping out on taxes might sound appealing at a glance, but Crockett herself admits it’s a shaky proposition, lacking in substance and consideration for the real economic standing of those it purports to help. What’s more, she notes the potential for chaos should there be discrepancies in reparations policies between federal and state levels, suggesting a poorly masked concern for a mass migration of individuals seeking the most lucrative deal.

Serving since 2023, Crockett has voiced criticism against those hesitant to even explore the concept of reparations properly, targeting opponents for their refusal to commit to studies or meaningful discourse. Yet, it’s this very lack of due diligence and foresight in her own proposals that starkly illustrates why many balk at the reparations narrative. It’s a narrative driven more by emotional appeal than by pragmatic considerations or the pursuit of policies that genuinely elevate communities.

Now, as Crockett faces reelection, her stance on reparations aligns with broader Democratic efforts in states like California and New York, where the push for reparative justice has led to discussions on direct payments, formal apologies, and even property returns. However, these actions, while grand in their ambition, often lack clarity on implementation, impact assessment, and, crucially, how they align with the principle of individual accountability and empowerment.

In essence, the reparations debate, as evidenced by Crockett’s tax exemption musing, is emblematic of a larger issue within the Democratic Party: a penchant for proposing sweeping, headline-grabbing solutions without the requisite groundwork to ensure they’re viable, equitable, or even truly desired by those they aim to serve. As America grapples with its historical injustices, it deserves more than just symbolic gestures or policies that sound good on paper but falter in reality. It requires a commitment to solutions that foster opportunity, responsibility, and genuine advancement for all its citizens.

Robert Chernin

Robert Chernin

Robert B. Chernin has brought his years of political consulting and commentary back to radio. As a longtime entrepreneur, business leader, fundraiser and political confidant, Robert has a unique perspective with insights not heard anyway else. Robert has consulted on federal and statewide campaigns at the gubernatorial, congressional, senatorial, and presidential level. He served in leadership roles in the presidential campaigns of President George W. Bush as well as McCain for President. He led Florida’s Victory 2004’s national Jewish outreach operations as Executive Director. In addition, he served on the President’s Committee of the Republican Jewish Coalition. Robert co-founded and served as president of the Electoral Science Institute, a non-profit organization that utilizes behavioral science to increase voter participation and awareness. Robert can be heard on multiple radio stations and viewed on the “Of the People” podcast where you get your podcasts.