Skip to content

Violent Crime Decreases Following Florida’s Enactment of Constitutional Carry

Contrary to critics' predictions, Florida's permitless carry law correlates with a significant drop in violent crimes.

The passage of Florida’s House Bill 543, establishing constitutional carry in the state, marked a significant moment in the ongoing national debate over gun rights. Despite widespread media and Democrat opposition, the law’s implementation did not bring about the catastrophic consequences predicted by its critics. In fact, since its enactment on July 1, 2023, Florida has witnessed a decrease in violent crimes, including shootings, challenging the narrative that less restrictive gun laws lead to more violence.

Opponents of constitutional carry, including prominent figures in the corporate media and the Democrat Party, were quick to express their disapproval when Florida became the 26th state to adopt such legislation. Headlines from NBC News and rhetoric from gun control groups like Giffords labeled the law as “dangerous” and “extreme.” The White House, too, condemned the move, with Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre criticizing Governor Ron DeSantis for weakening “commonsense gun safety.”

However, the data from Florida’s major cities in the months following the law’s implementation tells a different story. In Jacksonville, murders and homicides saw a 6% decline from the previous year. Miami recorded an even more impressive decrease in violent crimes, with the lowest number of homicides ever and a 34% drop in non-fatal shootings.

These statistics suggest that constitutional carry may have played a role in deterring crime. The notion that “good guys with guns” can prevent, deter, and even stop criminal activities seems to be supported by these figures. This is in line with studies showing that lawful gun owners rarely commit crimes like mass shootings. Instead, legal gun ownership under constitutional carry laws underscores the Second Amendment right of Americans to defend themselves and others.

The case of Florida is particularly significant given the state’s history with high-profile shootings. The decline in violent crimes in the wake of constitutional carry’s enactment is a testament to the effectiveness of policies that respect the rights of law-abiding citizens to bear arms. Far from the chaos and violence predicted by critics, Florida’s experience demonstrates that empowering individuals to exercise their Second Amendment rights can contribute to a safer society.

This outcome in Florida should prompt a reevaluation of the commonly held beliefs about gun laws and crime rates. The fearmongering tactics used by opponents of constitutional carry have not been borne out by the facts on the ground. Instead, we are seeing that responsible gun ownership, supported by laws that respect individual rights, can be a part of the solution to America’s crime problems.

In the broader context of the national debate on gun control, Florida’s experience is a reminder that the rights enshrined in the Constitution, including the Second Amendment, are there for a reason. They protect the liberties of citizens and, as Florida’s case shows, can contribute to a safer and more secure society.

In conclusion, Florida’s constitutional carry law serves as a compelling case study in the ongoing debate over gun rights in America. The decrease in violent crime following its implementation suggests that empowering citizens to exercise their Second Amendment rights can play a significant role in enhancing public safety. It’s a lesson that policymakers and the public should consider as we continue to seek effective solutions to reduce violence and protect our communities.

American Coalition

American Coalition

The American Coalition operates as a 501(c)(4) non-profit organization, as amended, created by Americans who have tired of the ever-growing assault on the foundation of our entire way of life.